Many things i thought i knew regarding stalin are indeed lies. It is an undesirable, yet firm, reality that individuals who. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Otherwise, the chapters in this book go far to explaining stalins rise to. Joseph stalin has 158 books on goodreads with 6708 ratings. Waiting for hitler, 19291941 pulitzer prizefinalist stephen kotkin has written the definitive biography of joseph stalin, from collectivization and the. The recent declassification of a substantial portion of stalins archive has made possible this fundamental new assessment of the soviet leader. Another view of stalin analyzes a series of media lies.
Princeton historian stephen kotkin gives a less tendentious and more balanced interpretation of the. A history, and im very interested in reading more about stalin and to a lesser extent lenin and trotsky. Concerning certain distortions of stalins work and l. Posts about book another view of stalin written by other aspect. Adopting another view of stalin means looking at the historic stalin through the eyes of the oppressed class, through the eyes of the exploited and oppressed. His real name was dzhugashvili also spelled dzugashvili or djugashvili. My main impression, as far as i can remember, is that a lot of it is useful as a weapon against propaganda both on the past and present of communism that we are often confronted with. Unfortunately for many, life under stalin was one full of. Another view of stalin, out of print book is back in print thanks to our comrades on prolespod. He argues that focusing on stalin alone has, for too long, provided simple and convenient interpretation when the real story is much more complicated. Yaroshenko on a projected primer on marxist economics. Shattering some of the stalinhitler myths deathride revises much about tyrants deathride looks at the relationship between josef stalin pictured and adolf hitler.
Arch getty, in his book the origins of the great purges 1985, put the most extreme case of the revisionists. The book deserves the broad audience it may struggle to find and will surely stand for years to. Buy another view of stalin 1st by ludo martens, john plaice isbn. An inquiry into the sons and daughters of dictators, is published tomorrow.
The first volume of a new biography argues that stalin had social as well as organizational skills. Major theoretical writings, 190552 edited with an introduction by bruce franklin stalin is clearly one of the three most important historical figures of our century, his thought and deeds still affecting our daily lives, considered by hundreds of millions today as one of. The awardwinning author of villa airbel returns with a painstakingly researched, revelatory biography of svetlana stalin, a woman fated to live her life in the shadow of one of historys most monstrous dictatorsher father, josef stalin. A frenzy of hunting for spies and subversives shook the soviet union in the late 1930s, as joseph stalin propelled his police to unmask trotskyitefascists, rightist and leftist deviationists. This book provides a wideranging history of every aspect of stalins dictatorship over the peoples of the soviet union. First published as a pamphlet and frequently reprinted, the essay by the ethnic georgian stalin was regarded as a seminal contribution to marxist analysis of the nature of nationality and helped. Volume 1 paradoxes of power, 18781928, the first of his planned threevolume biography of. This book suggests a very different picture of stalins rise. According to this universally accepted view, hitler, joined by mussolini and the japanese warlords, cunningly orchestrated the political and military incidents which led to the.
A radical new theory of the origins of the second world war. More than half of this new book is devoted to the year after stalins death, when his old gang the. That is an ordinary practical man who could empathise with the problems of workers and peasants and have real solutions to problems rather than overblown rhetoric. The more we learn of josef stalin, the more alluring he becomes. But kotkin makes clear that the wars slaughter fields also confirmed the bolshevik view that the capitalistimperialist system was. Soviet russia in the 1930s, we are given a world of knowledge surrounding how postrevolutionary russia was an everchanging situation.
Lenins testament, the collectivization imposed by a. It was said that stalin only allowed from six books to be published as a present to his daughter, svetlana, who was a great admirer of akhmatovas work. It places the man and his ideology into context both within prerevolutionary russia, lenins soviet union and post. However, one should remember that it is literally another view. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. His library was a working one, not for show, and included books that had been banned and by rivals.
Communist party privilege protected her from the mass starvation and purges that haunted russia, but she did not escape tragedythe loss of everyone she loved, including her mother, two brothers, aunts and uncles, and a lover twice her age, deliberately exiled to siberia by her father. The cartoonist speculates that yaroshenko may find that. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. In his book he seems to take a lot of responsibility for the purges away from stalin. As a nonmarxistindeed an antimarxisti found the chapter on stalin as a marxist irritating. The essential stalin by usw c4 of united struggle from within may 2012 permalink. And for this reason, she had another view of stalin. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. The last days of stalin is an engaging, briskly told account of the dictators final active months, the vigil at his deathbed, and the unfolding of soviet and international events in the months after his death. Comments on a controversy in the soviet union in which stalin criticized a debate by several soviet economists including l.
This book by ludo martens of the workers party of belgium, another view of stalin epo, antwerp. When the reader finishes reading this book, he will probably say. Drawing on unexplored archives and personal testimonies gathered from across russia and georgia, this is the first fullscale biography of the. Born in the early years of the soviet union, svetlana stalin spent her youth inside the walls of the kremlin. Terror and killing and more killing under stalin leading. He read widely, including books in foreign languages. The extraordinary and tumultuous life of svetlana alliluyeva by sullivan, rosemary isbn.
We consider certain parts of stalins life, as presented in the book, stalin, man of. Adopting another view of stalin means looking at the historic stalin through. The book refutes the classical attacks against stalin. Perpetrators, bystanders, and rescu ers, in which he proposes the idea that a lack of maturation. This book is not designed to be a biography of stalin.
He read history and marxist philosophy, he read popularized science, he also read fiction voraciously. Cartoon shows stalin with a bayonet driving a bound figure labeled professor yaroshenko up steps made of piles of paper to a gallows. Stephen kotkin recounts the early life and political ascendancy of joseph stalin in his book, stalin. View entire discussion 5 comments more posts from the askhistorians community. Based on groundbreaking research, simon sebag montefiore reveals in captivating detail the fear. The figure of joseph stalin has always provoked heated and often polarized debate. Many russians felt that communism could be the answer to their prayers. In this groundbreaking 2005 study, leading international experts challenge many assumptions about stalin from his early life in georgia to the cold war years with. Are there any books andor biographies that are a must read. Drawing upon a huge array of primary and secondary sources, the stalin era is a firsthand account of stalinist thought, policy and and their effects. A portrait of stalin in all his murderous contradictions. Volume 1, paradoxes of power, 18781928, by stephen kotkin. Stalin that is imposed on us daily is that of the class that wants to maintain the existing system of exploitation and oppression. This book was hailed by many unsuspected and well intentioned.
Kotkins most recent book is his first of three planned volumes, which discuss the life and times of the soviet dictator joseph stalin. S vetlana stalin merits a little space in this magazine. In 1994, martens published another view of stalin, a history of the soviet union under stalin that challenges in particular the dominant view of collectivization in the ussr and the great purge. It is intended to directly confront the standard attacks made against stalin. Winner of the british book awards history book of the yearlonglisted for the samuel johnson prizethis thrilling biography of stalin and his entourage during the terrifying decades of his supreme power transforms our understanding of stalin as soviet dictator, marxist leader and russian tsar. The message of the book, it seemed, was that being one of stalins relatives was nearly as terrible as being one of his subjects. Incorporating an extensive range of materials, including the personal experiences of many people who lived through the stalinist years, medvedev, a dissident soviet historian, reassesses stalins character and actions in a withering indictment of the stal. Joseph stalins most popular book is dialectical and historical materialism. Defending stalins work, essentially defending marxismleninism, is an important, urgent.
For reasons that seem obvious, if a little ghoulish, readers cant get enough of josef stalin and the horrors he committed. Stalins daughter svetlana alliluyeva was touched by. Another view of stalin, by ludo martens the online books page. List of books and articles about joseph stalin online. When the reader finishes reading this book, they will probably say. He explained his motivation for writing the book in the introduction. Stalin after in his road to power was happy to portray himself in a similar way to the trotsky caricature of him. With every new edition the contents of this book underwent considerable change. Another view of stalin by ludo martens paperback lulu. Another view of stalin, out of print book is back in. When the reader finishes reading this book, he will probably.
1189 404 3 516 255 793 1150 737 1091 1403 902 821 404 585 1353 1250 631 125 791 703 1235 834 555 609 1188 336 1321 398 762 710 206 1449 1005 538 826 1421 296 41 543 528 159 1425 1297